1. Keys Fisheries

One of Marathon’s most iconic dining destinations, this waterfront seafood market and restaurant is renowned for its Lobster Reuben sandwich and fresh Florida stone crab claws. Visitors love the casual dockside atmosphere and authentic Keys experience. Local travelers and food enthusiasts frequently rank it on the list of places to eat in marathon.

Highlights

Fresh local seafood

Waterfront dining

Lobster Reuben

Stone crab season specialties

2. Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar

A longtime local favorite, Castaway combines fresh seafood, sushi, and waterfront views. It has earned praise from both travel guides and locals for its quality seafood and relaxed atmosphere. Many visitors recommend it for supper and date nights.

Highlights

Fresh sushi and seafood

Waterfront setting

Extensive beer selection

Great happy hour options

3. Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House

Perfect for travelers seeking over seafood, this restaurant serves premium steaks, lobster, sushi, and classic Keys dishes. It’s consistently rated among Marathon’s top dining destinations and is ideal for special occasions or family dinners.

Highlights

Aged steaks

Fresh lobster

Sushi menu

Family-friendly atmosphere

4. Island Fish

Offering beautiful Gulf views as well as a lively tiki-bar atmosphere, Island Fish is known for fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and spectacular sunsets. It’s a great choice for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.

Highlights

Sunset waterfront dining

Tropical drinks

Fresh local seafood

Family-friendly environment

5. Burdines Waterfront

A marina-side favorite known for homemade hushpuppies, seafood baskets, burgers, and scenic harbor views. Travelers frequently recommend Burdines for lunch and casual dinners.

Highlights

Marina views

Famous hushpuppies

Casual atmosphere

Great burgers and seafood

6. Sparky’s Landing Fish and Cocktails

This waterfront tiki-style restaurant offers seafood, barbecue, cocktails, and wood-fired pizzas. It’s popular due to the relaxed outdoor seating and exquisite water views.

Highlights

Oceanfront seating

Seafood and cocktails

Happy hour specials

Casual island vibe

7. The Stuffed Pig

Widely considered one of the most effective breakfast spots in Marathon, The Stuffed Pig continues to be serving locals and visitors for many years. Its hearty breakfasts and seafood-inspired morning dishes transform it into a must-visit.

Highlights

Legendary breakfast menu

Lobster Benedict

Family-owned atmosphere

Local favorite

Honorable Mentions

Barracuda Grill – Upscale seafood and steak dining.

Porky’s Bayside Restaurant and Marina – Waterfront barbecue and seafood.

7 Mile Grill – Casual local favorite in the morning and seafood.

Marathon’s restaurant scene reflects the relaxed spirit of the Florida Keys. Whether you’re craving fresh lobster, sushi, stone crab, barbecue, or possibly a waterfront sunset dinner, you will find plenty of memorable dining options. For first-time visitors, Keys Fisheries, Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar, and Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House are excellent places to start your culinary journey through Marathon.